Scripted series · UPtv
Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries
Who's in it
Cast
The principal ensemble across the run of the series.
The Nutevio profile
TV DNA
How Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries actually feels to watch, measured on the traits our editors track across every series.
Signature profile
Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries reads strongest on Bingeability, Cliffhanger Intensity and Tension.
How hard it is to stop after one episode.
How often an episode ends on a hook you can't ignore.
The sustained pressure the series keeps you under.
How much each hour depends on the one before it.
How fully written and psychologically layered the ensemble is.
How much the series is designed to affect you.
Visual ambition — scale, craft and set-piece filmmaking.
The scale, internal logic and texture of the world.
How often the series is genuinely funny, by design.
The story
What it's about
After a breakup, Cheryl takes over an Amish gift shop in Sugarcreek. Strange stuffed animals, a kidnapping, and hidden feuds force her, Naomi, and Levi into a thrilling search.
Recently aired
Latest Episodes
Behind the series
Created by
Showrunners, creators, executive producers and the writers who set the voice of the series.
Where to watch
Streaming
Availability verified against regional listings.
- Amazon Prime VideoStreaming
- YouTube TVStreaming
- UP Faith & Family Apple TV ChannelStreaming
- Amazon Prime Video with AdsStreaming
- UP Faith & Family Amazon Channel Streaming
Where to go from here
Watch Next
Our editors' suggestion for the show you should start tonight — and why.
FROM
2022
Continue the epic fantasy journey with another world worth getting lost in.
Wednesday
2022
Another invented world built with the same seriousness — start at episode one.
High Potential
2024
A crime story told with the patience of a novel.
The Apothecary Diaries
2023
Take the questions with you: this one rewards the same attention.
The Originals
2013
Another invented world built with the same seriousness — start at episode one.
Sherlock
2010
A crime story told with the patience of a novel.
Never stop watching
Related Collections
No related collections yet
This title isn't in a published Nutevio collection yet. It will appear here automatically as soon as it is.
Join the conversation